Seatrade Cruise News is part of the Informa Markets Division of Informa PLC

This site is operated by a business or businesses owned by Informa PLC and all copyright resides with them. Informa PLC's registered office is 5 Howick Place, London SW1P 1WG. Registered in England and Wales. Number 8860726.

Sentences handed down in New Zealand’s White Island tragedy

CRUISE_White_Island_volcano_0.jpg
The White Island volcano case dragged on for four years
More than four years after a volcano erupted on New Zealand’s White Island, killing 22 people and leaving others with horrific burns, six parties were sentenced in the Auckland District Court on Friday for health and safety failings.

As reported here, passengers from Royal Caribbean International’s Ovation of the Seas were on a day trip to the island when the volcano erupted in December 2019.

Fines and reparation

Whakaari Management Limited, the company of White Island owners James, Andrew and Peter Buttle, was fined NZ$1.045m and is to pay total reparation of NZ$4.88m. 

White Island Tours was fined NZ$517,000 and is to pay total reparation of NZ$5m.

Volcanic Air Safaris was fined NZ$506,000 and is to pay total reparation of NZ$330,000.

Helicopter companies Aerius and Kahu were fined NZ$290,000 and NZ$196,000 respectively.

GNS (Institute of Geological and Nuclear Sciences) that hired helicopter pilots to fly staff to the volcano for fieldwork, was fined NZ$54,000.

‘Heart-breaking’ stories

Judge Evangelos Thomas told the court victims’ stories had been ‘heartbreaking’ and said four years was far too long to wait for their voices to be heard.

Thomas, who has overseen the matter since late 2020 when charges were laid, said the court acknowledged the ongoing pain felt by survivors and the grief felt by the families of victims.

WorkSafe New Zealand argued that appropriate fines be imposed, even if the parties involved were not able to pay them.